The scenario the 'ticking bomb' problem the problem that even the most virtuous people face when thinking about torture is whether there is ever a case when a good result produced by torture. Ethical arguments regarding torture the ethical question is whether this can ever be justified wolfgang daschner felt that in the circumstances it was justified. Is torture ever justified essay - in this case, it is in regard to the due process rights of terrorist suspects and the use of torture is the use of torture on. Can torture ever be justified round ii torture can never be justified maybe the use of torture produced information that enabled our forces to stop x number of terrorist attacks.
Torture can be defined as, 'the act of inflicting excruciating pain, as punishment or revenge, as a means of getting a confession or information, or for sheer cruelty'(dershowitz, a) according to international law, it is illegal to use torture in any situation of any kind. I will now present an argument for the use of torture in rare circumstances while many people have objected, on emotional grounds, to my defense of torture, no one has pointed out a flaw in my. Is torture ever justified item preview remove-circle the use of torture serves current us foreign policy objectives / glen t martin.
The real issue, which we have not, unfortunately, come to grips with, is what techniques, falling well short of torture, can we use in interrogating captured unlawful enemy combatants, who as a. Torture under normal circumstances does not seem to garner a lot of popular support but there is a commonly debated reasoning as to a justified use of torture the scenario is generally termed the ticking bomb situation (schweiker, 2008, santucci, 2008, hunsinger, 2008, kleinig, 2005, & bufacchi and arrigo, 2006. The ticking time bomb scenario is a thought experiment that has been used in the ethics debate over whether torture can ever be justified as a thought experiment.
Constitutional rights foundation bill of rights in action is torture ever justified international law prohibits nations from using torture under any. Is the use torture ever justified essay sample according time in the follow asian, middle east and other countries have used torture as a tool of murder for over two thousand years. A timeline documenting the history of torture in the united states torture in the united states administration had ordered the use of torture against two al. Is the use torture ever justified according time in the follow asian, middle east and other countries have used torture as a tool of murder for over two thousand.
Can torture ever be justified as part of the perspectives series, bbc religion and ethics asked two contributors to bbc one's religious debate programme the big questions to develop some of the. More than four in ten americans (43%) say that the use of torture can be justified to gain key information sometimes (31%) or often (12%. The unspeakable / to get at the truth, is torture or coercion ever justified vicki haddock, insight staff writer published 4:00 am pst, sunday, november 18, 2001. Yes, christians can support torture majorities of christians support the use of torture in some instances and they're not bad christians for doing so or 1776 if war is ever justified. Terrorist groups use torture why shouldn't the united states humane treatment of prisoners and detainees is a fundamental part of american ideals and values.
Justification of use of torture against suspected terrorists 2014, by party do you think the use of torture against suspected terrorists is ever justified (by political affiliation. After refusing at her confirmation hearing to condemn the cia's use of torture after 9/11, she wrote in a letter that the agency should not have undertaken that program. Why torture is never justified is torture ever justified the answer was a resounding no here's why: there is never a time to use torture, never.
Is torture ever justified countries should be authorized to use torture to obtain intelligence when terrorists can annihilate thousands of people for no reason. Can the use of torture be justified officially a thing of the dark ages, torture is still used today many prisoners of war are tortured for information, as are suspects in malicious crimes. Torture is way more effective that other interrogation techniques with the exception of use of leverages eg threatening to rape/kill their wife and kids if they don't cooperate if the information extracted is incorrect, then you will have to torture them further or kill some members of their family as a demonstration of your power.
The only way that torture can ever be justified is if it is to gain information about an imminent threat to lives i see your point but what is an iminant threat to life wmds activated in 45 minutes, perhaps. Torture is justifiable the limited use of torture should be permitted in the us in order to protect the wellbeing of the public torture can be both an effective means of gathering information, and it can be reasonably justified in some circumstances. Is torture ever justified by bernard goldberg may 6, review and training to minimize this possibility and to only use torture in narrowly defined cases. Is torture acceptable if it helps save thousands of lives i have proposed that under no circumstances should torture ever be permitted without a judicial warrant reasonable people will.